By Jim and Susan Vogt
Global warming is a hot topic these days, but what does it have to do with faith?
“Have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the air and over
every living thing…. See, I have given to you every plant…every tree….
God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good” (Genesis 1:28-31). “The
Lord God took the man and put him in the garden of Eden to till it and keep it”
How are we to cultivate and take care of the earth? Scripture can’t
mean that everyone must become farmers! It does mean, however, that we all have a responsibility
to care for the earth. These are easy words to agree to in theory. After all, it feels
wholesome to commit to caring for the earth. Being good stewards of creation is wholly
holy, natural and reasonable. But it isn’t as easy as it sounds. Consider the following
The Consumer’s Guide to Effective Environmental Choices identifies
the use of automobiles as the single most environment- damaging consumer behavior, so
Jim urged Susan to take the bus to work. He often rode it himself. After all, we live
on a bus line, and it would be “good for Susan’s soul.” Jim explained
that Susan could use the time to read, meditate and be in solidarity with those who don’t
have transportation choices. This quadrupled a 20-minute commute once transfers and waiting
were factored in. Susan countered,
“That’s two hours I could spend at work or with our family. Plus, I lose
the flexibility to do errands on the way home, making additional trips necessary.” Susan
tried it. She still does it occasionally—
for her soul—but there are competing values. What would you do?
Growing some produce ourselves is good stewardship. It provides fresh healthy
food, saves money and trips to the store, and can be satisfying to the spirit, not to
mention good exercise. (Assuming you don’t overdo it and have to go to a chiropractor
afterwards as Susan once did.) But what about those pesky critters and insects that can
delete the fruits of our hard work more quickly than we can delete spam? Should we use
pesticides on crops, poison the moles or spend extra on organic remedies? What if our
kids won’t eat the apples because they don’t look as pretty as the ones in
Two of our children live in foreign countries. Visiting them is a family-bonding
experience that also raises our awareness of other cultures—especially the hardships
faced by people in Africa and India. Of course, airfare is expensive, and air travel
leaves a heavy carbon footprint. But what if our travel didn’t involve family but
simply the enriching experience of learning about another country? Would it be better
to send a donation to a charity in a developing country than travel to experience it?
We know that traditional incandescent light bulbs use three to four times
more electricity than energy-efficient ones, but the environmentally friendly ones can
look garish. Do aesthetics trump energy savings?
There are plenty of other thorny conundrums for conscientious Christians
who want to honor God’s creation by preserving and protecting it. In the end, many
of us just get tired of the complexity and mixed messages, throw up our hands and murmur, “What
difference will it make to the ozone if I recycle a few soda cans each week?”
What each of us does, however, can make a difference. First, we must take
personal responsibility for our own actions. Whether it’s refraining from lying,
caring for those in need or respecting the environment, our own actions are the ones
we control. We must start by responding consistently to God’s call to be faithful
stewards of creation. In addition, there is the dimension of witness. Who knows when
someone might see our small efforts at recycling and decide to do something similar?
Then there is the reality that, as members of the human community, we are
not isolated beings dependent only on ourselves. Dispiriting murmurs should be passed
through the prism of community. Instead of “What difference will my action make?” we
“What if everyone took my action?”
What if everyone just threw their soda cans into the trash? What if everyone recycled
them? The “everyone” test can often help us see more clearly.
As Christian stewards of creation, however, we must not only change our
own lifestyles, but also work to change systems. As good as it may be to begin using
energy-efficient light bulbs, it will make a bigger impact if we work to create systemic
change. This means taking the trouble to lobby government officials for “green” legislation
or contact civic leaders about cleaning up polluting industries. Yes, we may have to
pay a little more for products in the short run, but we will all pay sooner or later
in terms of health and, ultimately, survival. Prevention is always cheaper in the long
Another effective “green” thing we can do is support an environmental
advocacy group. Taking personal action is often the first step, but we must move from
changing a light bulb to changing the system in order to make a real and lasting dent.
This approach multiplies our efforts exponentially.
Perhaps we can revisit the familiar maxim “What would Jesus do?” and
“Was Jesus an environmentalist?”Well, he did walk a lot, ate organic and
local, drank the local water and didn’t depend on electricity. Even his garment
was recycled at his crucifixion. But he didn’t have a choice. We do. Jesus sent
us the Spirit to breathe new life into our troubled souls and world. Let us not pollute
the gift of creation lest it die on our watch—or on that of our children’s
Can one be a faithful follower of Christ and not care for the earth?
Why or why not?
How seriously are you taking your own responsibility for being a
steward of creation? How is this played out in action? What more could you do?
Identify moments of courage or conviction in your own life. How do
you react when you encounter injustices, large or small, that affect the world
we live in?
A Civil Action
By Frank Frost
Near the end of the movie A Civil Action, we see, in flashback,
some teenage boys taunting a man across a large drainage pond, throwing lighted firecrackers
at him in the dark. We know the man has illegally dumped toxic chemical waste from his
tannery into the pond, escaping detection for a number of years. Suddenly the pond ignites
and, as we watch the flames leap fiercely into the night, we recognize what it symbolizes:
An unseen hazard of toxic waste possesses unpredictable power to do harm.
We do in fact already know, from earlier scenes, some of the damage this
contaminated water has wreaked: children dead of leukemia, adults disabled with serious
illnesses. And while A Civil Action is basically a courtroom drama about corporate
greed and overreaching by personal injury lawyers, another message also comes across:
Such flagrant abuse of the environment could not happen without the passive—and
active—participation of many ordinary people.
After one conscience-stricken employee decides to testify about waste-dumping
at his plant, his fellow workers react by shunning him. Their jobs are more important
than correcting the problem. For them, the cost of changing the situation is as high
as it is for the corporations involved, or for the attorney who goes broke pursuing the
A Civil Action, based on a real case, is a complex story that allows
for moral shading, depicting a world where selfish decisions made by many people can
impact the health of a community. One protagonist is a woman of constant courage. Others
show only brief moments of courage. Only one man is deliberate in his evil choices. Others
are simply “doing their jobs.”
Next time you watch A Civil Action, ASK YOURSELF:
■ What are moments of conversion for Jan Schlichtmann? When
did the case stop being about making money for him?
■ Jan risked (and lost) a lot in order to right a terrible
wrong, yet many of us don’t even bother to recycle. What motivated Jan?
■ What motivates you to care for the earth?
Sr. Carolyn Hoff, O.S.F.
By Joan McKamey
Long before becoming director of Michaela Farm, a farm renewal project
of the Oldenburg Franciscans in southeastern Indiana, Sr. Carolyn Hoff was often found
outdoors. She spent 18 years working in Catholic high schools, later running the retreat
center and supervising housekeeping at her order’s motherhouse, and everywhere
she worked, she tells Every Day Catholic, “Other Sisters could always find
me outside on weekends or days off, sprucing up the yard.”
Directing Michaela Farm is a good fit for nature-loving Sr. Carolyn. A
family farm of the Sisters of St. Francis since 1854, it has recently been revitalized
to increase awareness of ecological concerns. Its 300 acres include pastures, hayfields,
woodlands, prairie, fallow land and gardens. At present, beefalo (a mix of buffalo and
cattle) provide the Sisters with rich natural fertilizer (a.k.a. “black gold”)
and grass-fed, lean meat. Michaela Farm is grounded in the Franciscan value of “just
relationships with all Creation.” This is expressed in simple living, seeing all
creation as “kin,”
respectful use of resources, striving for sustainability, and offering gratitude, hospitality
and sharing. Beyond supplying the motherhouse residents with fresh produce, the Sisters
share the bounty of the harvest with families on limited incomes. They also share their
property and vision of ecological stewardship through tours, volunteer opportunities,
educational events and a donor tree program.
Sr. Carolyn—and all Franciscans—
find inspiration in St. Francis of Assisi’s naming of all created things as our
brothers and sisters. Sr. Carolyn finds particular inspiration in two parables—it’s
no surprise that they’re about nature—the sower and the seed (Matthew 13:3-9)
and the barren fig tree (Luke 13:6-9). Of the first, she says,
“Not all projects, trees, plants or vegetables fall on good soil, so I continually
need to evaluate what is happening. I also must evaluate what I have done to spread the
idea or seed in the wrong place.”
In the second parable, a gardener convinces a landowner to spare a barren
fig tree for one year during which he will cultivate and fertilize it in hope that it
will bear fruit. Sr. Carolyn relates this story to her “love of trying to nurture
trees and plants or the land to good health.” She says that it is a reminder to “be
patient with whatever comes my way at any given moment.”
Sr. Carolyn reflects on her passion for caring for the earth: “The
beauty of what God created always inspires and relaxes me. Standing on top of the rolling
hills of the farm and looking around and quietly listening to nature can be breathtaking.
I also like being down in a valley, feeling small with all the tall hills and trees around.”
St. Francis, the patron of her religious community, is remembered yearly
on his feast day, October 4. This is a special day for Sr. Carolyn who says, “I
usually take extra time to visit the animals, walk the land and thank God I’m here—wherever here is
at that moment.”
Its Not Easy Being Green
By Jeanne Hunt
Jon, Erin and their young son walk silently back to their car. The state
park is closed. The drought has taken its toll: The parched earth is a fire hazard and
the water level is too low for swimming and boating. “Daddy, how can we fix the
brown grass and the dirty water?” their son, Elijah, asks. They have no answer
for him. Elijah simply presumes that it is fixable. His daddy and mommy can do anything.
Growing up in the Midwest, I believed that this good, green earth would
be there in all its beauty forever. It was self-maintaining, and all I had to do was
soak up the pleasure of its bounty. Now I see a different picture: The summers grow hotter,
the water is not safe to drink, the air is polluted, trees and animals are dying and
the land is being depleted of its resources. So, what can I do to restore the well-being
of our earth?
The scenario of the young family out for a day at the park is all too familiar.
Recent droughts have been devastating. The normally abundant farms have struggled for
a meager crop. We need to correct the wrong we have done so that parents like Erin and
Jon can pass on a living earth to their children. Families can begin to do simple things
that will offer hope to children and teach the lessons of good stewardship. We are tempted
to succumb to the despair of helplessness. Yet, whatever we do is far better than doing
nothing. In the doing, we teach our children to act justly, love tenderly and walk humbly
with God (Micah 6:8). Here are a few simple ideas that can become part of every family’s
Plant gardens and trees. Each living thing offers a return to the earth.
In the planting, we teach our children the grace of keeping the earth green.
Recycle everything! Creatively reuse what you have. Never have more of
anything than you can use.
Use resources such as fuel and coolants sparingly. Ration the amount of
fuel you purchase and learn to conserve.
Avoid using paper products. Cloth napkins and ceramic mugs are better options
at your table and workplace.
Pray for the earth and all its inhabitants that we will have the grace
to keep this planet in the fashion God intended.